Choose one: Josh Hamilton or Cole Hamels

[RenoHightower]

Yea, ARod's production would have resulted in negative championships instead. My god, man.

I don't see a "heart," "grit," or "clutch" header on there.

[jcarey]

I hope that this question is intended as a theoretical exercise, because the Yankees are getting neither.

Theoretical exercise? I was under the impression that this thread, like all others on NYYF, would have a direct impact on upper-management decisionmaking.